The Taser's Edge

One of these things looks exactly like the other…

1.) WikiMedia’s recent release of footage of an airstrike in Baghdad.  (Warning: the video is a recording of human beings being shot to death at 2:09.)

2.) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare‘s level, “Death From Above”, for Xbox 360 and PS3.

Credit for the comparison between the Wikimedia video and the particular Modern Warfare level is due to NPR’s On the Media by way of dotCommonweal.  From the NPR transcript:

BROOKE GLADSTONE: And video games are used to train soldiers. Part of the training is to sharpen skills, but people who train soldiers also say that part of it is to depersonalize the enemy.

CLIVE THOMPSON: Yeah, the military has actually spent like 100 to 200 years trying to get soldiers to kill people. One of the things they found, coming out of the First World War, was that a lot of soldiers, even faced with gunfire right in their face by the enemy, would not return fire. So the military worked for years on operant conditioning, you know, when something pops up, just sort of shoot at it, to get past this innate resistance to taking human life.

Something interesting to note.  I have heard before about video games being used by the military to desensitize soldiers to violence, enabling them to be more effective at what they do in war (killing people).  Yet, there is this odd distinction.  Video games have apparently been an effective way of getting soldiers to shoot at people rather than purposely missing or refusing to fire.  Yet, there is no proven correlation between playing violent video games and becoming more violent in the long-term.  Are those two observations at odds with each other?

2 Comments so far
Leave a comment

It’s more about sterilizing the actual effect shooting a “person” has on the individual firing the weapon. For example, during rifle training, the target you shoot at is a man sized/shaped target that “stands up” and will fall to the ground when successfully hit with a bullet, thus simulating a kill on the battlefield. For me, I find it interesting that people have such a pronounced reaction to actually viewing the military in real action like this, the same military that most everyone supports in theory and reviles in reality.

Comment by Eddie

Thanks for the comment, Eddie, especially making that connection to a much more low-tech simulation. When you put it that way, it seems like paintball and even laser tag would be much more desensitizing to the act of shooting a human than a video game, considering that they ask you to shoot a gun at a real human being. But I can’t remember ever hearing much about laser tag causing school shootings.

Finally, I really don’t understand all the hubbub about this particular video (of all the images of war and even of civilians being killed that are out there) either.

Comment by tasersedge

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: